Redefinition of the Scarcity Price: lessons and recommendations from the Colombian electricity market

Emanuel J. Llanos-Perez, Laura M. Hinestroza-Olascuaga


The Colombian government introduced a capacity market in order to promote the diversification in the energy matrix and protect users from high prices derived from dry seasonal events. Unfortunately, the flaws in the scarcity price definition- a mechanism that activates the capacity market obligation and sets a cap price for the spot market- have led into a market failure. Specifically, some generation plants have been forced to be unavailable because their variable costs are significantly higher than the scarcity price. This paper presents a qualitative and quantitative analysis of the Colombian Electricity system, with a particular emphasis on the definition of the scarcity price. Results present lessons and recommendations for policy makers based on the experience of the Colombian Electricity Market, highlighting the need of a new definition of the scarcity price and a different focus on the energy planning scheme.


Colombian energy system; energy market; energy planning; spot market price

Full Text:



J. Benavides, and I. Fainboim, “Private Participation in Infrastructure in Colombia-Renegotiation and Disputes”, in Basañes and R. Willig (Eds.), Second-Generation Reforms in Infrastructure Services, Chapter 4, pp. 89-132, 2002.

J. Pérez Arriaga, C. Solé-Martín, C. Vázquez Martínez, and C. Meseguer Velasco, “Formación de precios en generación y diseño del mercado mayorista en el sistema eléctrico colombiano”. Study prepared for the Colombian association of power producers- ACOLGEN. Bogotá, Colombia, 1999.

S. Arango, I. Dyner, and E. R. Larsen, “Lessons from deregulation: Understanding electricity markets in South America,” Util. Policy, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 196–207, 2006.

J. Millán, “La segunda generación de bolsas de energía: Lecciones para América Latina,” Interamerican Development Bank report, pp. 1–18, April 1999.

G. Cervigni and D. Perekhodtsev, “Wholesale Electricity Markets,” Econ. Electr. Mark. Theory Policy, pp. 1–17, January 2013.

Expertos en Mercados, XM, “Colombia´s installed capacity by generation source”, [Online], 2014. Available at: (accessed 15.01.16).

P. Cramton and S. Stoft, “Colombia Firm Energy Market: Summary,” Engineering, February, 2007.

COWI, “Impact analysis for integration of wind power generation in Colombia. 3, Market and regulatory aspects,” Progress study Report No.3, October, 2014.

Commission for the Regulation of Energy and Gas (CREG), “Reliability charge: regulatory scheme to guarantee the reliability in the supply of electric energy in Colombia, a long-term vision,”pp.1-15., 2007.

J. Pfeifenberger, K. Spees, and A. Schumacher, "A comparison of PJM’s RPM with alternative energy and capacity market designs. Prepared for PJM Interconnection, Inc.", [Online], 2009. Available at: (accessed: 01.10 2016).

Asociación Nacional de Empresas Generadoras, “Un Análisis del Precio de Escasez,” pp.1-28, 2014.

Expertos en Mercados, XM, “Información Cálculo del Precio de Escasez para el mes de octubre de 2015 según Resolución CREG 070 de 2014”, [Online], 2015. Available at: (accessed 15.02.2016).

Expertos en Mercados, XM, “Precio de escasez vs Precio de bolsa”, [Online], 2015. Available at:$kWh).aspx (accessed 14.01.2016).

P. Cramton, A. Ockenfels, and S. Stoft, “Capacity Market Fundamentals,” Econ. Energy Environ. Policy, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 1–21, 2013.

W. Hogan, “On an “Energy only” electricity market design for resource adequacy”. California ISO. 2005

S, Stoft, Power system economics. Journal of Energy Literature, Vol. 8, pp.94-99. 2002

J. Pfeifenberger, “Resource adequacy requirements, scarcity pricing and Electricity market design implications”, 2014. [Online]. Available at: _Requirements__Scarcity_Pricing__and_Electricity_Market_Design_Implications.pdf?1404 399120 (accessed 09.10.2016).

W. Hogan, “Electricity scarcity pricing through operating reserves: An ERCOT window of opportunity”. Harvard University. Cambridge (MA).2012.

Protomac Economics, “Independent Market Monitor for the ERCOT Wholesale Market: State of the Market Report for the ERCOT Wholesale Electricity Markets”, 2008. Available at: (accessed 05.10.2016).

W. Hogan, “Electricity scarcity pricing through operating reserves”. Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy, 2(2), 65-86. 2013.

H. Rudnick and J. Montero, “Second generation electricity reforms in Latin America and the California Paradigm”. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade, Vol. 2(1-2), pp.159-172, 2002.

J. Park, N. Ahn, Y. Yoon, K. Koh, and D.W Bunn, “Investment incentives in the Korean electricity market”. Energy Policy, Vol. 35(11), pp.5819-5828, 2007.

P. Cramton and S. Stoft, “The convergence of market designs for adequate generating capacity with special attention to the CAISO’s resource adequacy problem-A white paper for the electricity oversight board”, pp.1-72, 2006.

El Tiempo, “Millionaire debts to banks and generators, another deficit of Termocandelaria”, press, [Online], 2015. Available at: (accessed 11.01.2016).

National and Oceanic Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), “What is the El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) in a nutshell?,” [Online]. Available at: (accessed 09.03.2016).

D. Harbord, “Second Review of Firm Energy Auctions in Colombia,” pp. 1–20, March, 2012.

Electricaribe S.A. E.S.P., “Tariffs, subsidies and contributions”. [Online], 2016. (accessed 04.03.2016).

El Heraldo, “Asoenergía refuses possible increase in the energy price,” press, [Online], 2016. Available at: (accessed 05.04.2016)

Portafolio, “Generation plants threaten to deliver their companies to the Government,” press. [Online], 2016. Available at: (accessed 05.04.2016)

Commission for the Regulation of Energy and Gas (CREG), “Resolution No. 172 of 2015,” Regulatory resolution, 2015.

Unidad de Planeación Minero Energetica (UPME). “Incremental Operational Cost of Energy Blackout,” [Online]. Available at: (accessed 30.03.16).

Commission for the Regulation of Energy and Gas (CREG). “Resolution No. 178 of 2015,” Regulatory resolution, 2015.

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), “ENSO forecast,” [Online], March 2015. Available at: (accessed 30.03.16).

Ministerio de Minas y Energía, “Energy saving tips,” [Online], 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.03.16).

El Colombiano, “Late measures taken during energy crisis: experts,” press, [Online], 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.03.16).

El Tiempo, “Recommendations: programed black out in the centre of the country,” press, [Online], 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.03.16).

D. Southerton, A. McMeekin, and D. Evans, “International Review of Behaviour Change Initiatives,” Soc. Res. (New. York)., pp. 1–46, 2011.

G. Cooper, “Escaping the house: comfort and the California garden,” Building Research & Information., vol. 36, no. 4, pp. 373–380, 2008.

Ministerio de Minas y Energía de Colombia and Unidad de Planeación Minero Energética, “Plan de Expansión de Referencia: Generación, Transmisión 2006-2020,” 2006.

W. Vergara, A. Deeb, N. Toba, P. Cramton and I. Leino, “Wind Energy in Colombia: A Framework for Market Entry,” World Bank Study, pp. 1-120, 2010.

Official COP21 website. “COP - What’s it all about?,” [Online], 2015. Available at: (accessed 07.01.16).

F. Ferreira, “OLADE – Contribución al Desarrollo de Energías Renovables,” Seminario de Energía más Limpia, May, 2014.

Commission for the Regulation of Energy and Gas (CREG). “Análisis del precio de escasez-Resolution No. 047,” pp.1-15., 2007.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2017 Emanuel J. Llanos-Perez, Laura M. Hinestroza-Olascuaga

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

SSL Certificate